Otterbein Seniorlife: nursing homes, inspection results and fines
Otterbein Seniorlife has 20 nursing homes in this data. In their last three inspection cycles, 11 were cited at level G or higher (actual harm or immediate jeopardy), 20 had at least one health citation, and the 20 homes together had 598 health citations.
Medicare lists 9 fines totaling $168,595 against 6 of them, dated November 2, 2023 to February 26, 2026.
Source: Medicare (CMS) Provider Data Catalog, Health Deficiencies and Penalties, data updated October 1, 2026, retrieved November 13, 2026.
Every nursing home with inspection data
Sorted by the most serious level of citation (J to L, then G to I, then A to F), then by the number of citations at level G or higher, then by total fines. Click a column heading to sort another way.
| Otterbein at Maineville | Maineville, OH | 4 | 32 | K | 3 | $59,449 | 4.54 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Green Hills Center | West Liberty, OH | 3 | 16 | K | 1 | $16,801 | 3.76 |
| Otterbein Monclova | Monclova, OH | 2 | 41 | G | 3 | $47,171 | 4.41 |
| Otterbein New Albany | New Albany, OH | 1 | 61 | G | 2 | $23,980 | 4.85 |
| Otterbein Union Township | Batavia, OH | 4 | 26 | G | 2 | $7,008 | 4.12 |
| Otterbein Sunset Village | Sylvania, OH | 3 | 42 | G | 1 | — | 3.87 |
| Otterbein Tipp City | Tipp City, OH | 3 | 31 | G | 1 | — | 3.33 |
| Otterbein Loveland | Loveland, OH | 1 | 27 | G | 1 | — | — |
| Otterbein Portage Valley | Pemberville, OH | 4 | 27 | G | 1 | — | 3.34 |
| Otterbein Lebanon Retirement Community | Lebanon, OH | 5 | 20 | G | 1 | — | 3.84 |
| Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community | St Marys, OH | 4 | 20 | G | 1 | — | 3.64 |
| Otterbein Franklin Seniorlife Community Res & Com Care | Franklin, IN | 3 | 17 | F | 0 | $14,186 | 3.64 |
| Otterbein Gahanna | Gahanna, OH | 3 | 81 | F | 0 | — | 4.25 |
| Avalon by Otterbein at Perrysburg | Perrysburg, OH | 2 | 40 | F | 0 | — | 4.60 |
| Otterbein Springboro | Centerville, OH | 4 | 25 | F | 0 | — | 4.31 |
| Otterbein Sunset House | Toledo, OH | 3 | 24 | F | 0 | — | 4.30 |
| Otterbein-Cridersville | Cridersville, OH | 4 | 22 | F | 0 | — | 3.70 |
| Otterbein North Shore | Lakeside, OH | 5 | 21 | F | 0 | — | 5.06 |
| Otterbein Middletown | Franklin, OH | 4 | 19 | E | 0 | — | 3.99 |
| Otterbein at Granville | Granville, OH | 5 | 6 | D | 0 | — | 4.45 |
Columns: overall Medicare star rating (1 to 5); health citations from the last three inspection cycles; most serious scope-and-severity letter (A to L; G or higher means actual harm or immediate jeopardy); how many citations were at level G or higher; total fines in Medicare’s Penalties file (about the last three years); reported nurse staffing in hours per resident per day. A dash means Medicare reports no value.
How these numbers are made
All values come from the Medicare (CMS) Provider Data Catalog files Health Deficiencies, Penalties, Provider Information and State US Averages (data updated October 1, 2026; penalties file updated October 1, 2026). A citation (deficiency) is counted once per tag and inspection. “Last three inspection cycles” are the cycles Medicare publishes; they cover about three years. Fines are the sum of the fine amounts in the Penalties file. Nothing is rated or ranked by us: the order is only the stated sort. A citation shows what inspectors found on the dates given; read each home’s page and the inspection reports on Medicare Care Compare before you decide.