Medical emergency?Emergency? Call 911. Nearest emergency roomsNearest ERs

Nurse Practitioner

Caroline R. Benish McNamara, NP

Sees patients in Setauket, NY · New York

Summary

Caroline R. Benish McNamara, NP is a nurse practitioner at 113 Main St, Setauket, NY 11733. Phone: (631) 365-2095. Accepts Medicare assignment. In 2024, Caroline R. Benish McNamara had 61 Original Medicare patients and 477 services. NPI 1396981957. Source: CMS National Downloadable File, updated October 30, 2026; CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners, data year 2024.

  • Specialty: Nurse practitioner
  • Address: 113 Main St, Setauket, NY 11733 · Directions
  • Phone: (631) 365‑2095
  • Medicare: Accepts Medicare assignment
  • School: graduated 1994
  • Gender (as listed): Female

From official Medicare data

This page shows what Medicare's official clinician data says about Caroline R. Benish McNamara, joined by NPI number (data updated October 30, 2026). It is not a recommendation or a rating. Call the office or hospital to confirm before you go.

In a medical emergency, call 911.

Quick answers

Does Caroline R. Benish McNamara accept Medicare assignment?
Yes. Medicare's clinician data says Caroline R. Benish McNamara accepts Medicare assignment (the Medicare-approved amount as full payment for covered services), as of October 30, 2026. Ask the office to confirm before your visit.
How many Medicare patients does Caroline R. Benish McNamara see?
In 2024, CMS data shows 61 Original Medicare patients and 477 services for Caroline R. Benish McNamara. This counts Original Medicare only and measures volume, not quality.
What is Caroline R. Benish McNamara's NPI number?
1396981957. The NPI (National Provider Identifier) is the clinician's permanent federal ID; you can look it up in the official NPI Registry.

Medicare activity in 2024

Official CMS public-use data for Caroline R. Benish McNamara, data year 2024 (released May 21, 2026). It covers Original Medicare (fee-for-service) patients only, not Medicare Advantage or other insurance. It shows volume, not quality or outcomes. CMS hides any count of 10 or fewer patients.

Original Medicare patients61
Services billed to Medicare477
Different services or procedures11
Participating Medicare providerYes
Average age of these patients84

Most frequent services

  1. Residence visit for established patient with moderate level of medical decision making, per day, if using time, at least 40 minutes (99349)204 services
  2. Chronic care management services, first 20 minutes of clinical staff time directed by health care professional, per calendar month (99490)193 services
  3. Residence visit for new patient with high level of medical decision making, per day, if using time, at least 75 minutes (99345)21 services
  4. Administration of influenza virus vaccine (G0008)18 services
  5. Influenza vaccine, trivalent, 0.5 ml dosage (90658)12 services

Chronic conditions among these patients

Share of this clinician’s Original Medicare patients with each condition, as published by CMS (it describes the patients, not the care given).

  • High blood pressure75%
  • High cholesterol75%
  • Heart failure75%
  • Diabetes70%
  • Arthritis51%
  • Ischemic heart disease46%

Practice locations

Addresses where Caroline R. Benish McNamara is enrolled with Medicare (CMS data updated October 30, 2026).

Specialties

Find other clinicians: Nurse Practitioner, New York →

Other nurse practitioners in New York

Clinicians with the same Medicare primary specialty in New York — not a recommendation.

All nurse practitioners in New York →

Clinician information

CredentialNP
Graduation year1994
Gender (as listed)Female
Medicare assignmentAccepts (Medicare-approved amount as full payment)
NPI (National Provider Identifier)1396981957
CorrectionsReport an error or suggest an update →

Most corrections must be made at the source: clinicians update their NPI Registry record (NPPES) and their Medicare enrollment (PECOS); this page follows the next data release.

Sources

  1. National Downloadable File — CMS, data updated October 30, 2026, retrieved November 14, 2026
  2. Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners - by Provider — CMS, data year 2024, released May 21, 2026; Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners - by Provider and Service
  3. NPI Registry — U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (NPPES), the clinician’s official record
  4. Medicare Care Compare — official Medicare tool to look up clinicians