Best Nursing Homes in Erie, PA: Medicare Star Ratings
14 nursing homes in Erie ranked by their Medicare overall star rating, highest first.
Nursing Homes in Erie, highest rated first
| # | Name | Overall | Health inspections | Staffing | Quality measures | Beds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lecom at Elmwood Gardens, LLC | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 5 of 5 stars | Staffing: 4 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 5 of 5 stars | 51 |
| 2 | LECOM at Asbury Ridge dba Saint Mary's Asbury Ridg | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 5 of 5 stars | Staffing: 4 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 4 of 5 stars | 80 |
| 3 | Forestview | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 4 of 5 stars | Staffing: 5 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 5 of 5 stars | 80 |
| 3 | Manchester Commons of Presbyterian Seniorcare | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 4 of 5 stars | Staffing: 5 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 5 of 5 stars | 78 |
| 5 | Pennsylvania Soldiers and Sailors Home | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 4 of 5 stars | Staffing: 5 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 2 of 5 stars | 107 |
| 5 | The Ball Pavilion | Overall: 5 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 4 of 5 stars | Staffing: 5 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 2 of 5 stars | 85 |
| 7 | Sarah Reed Senior Living | Overall: 4 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 5 of 5 stars | Staffing: 1 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 4 of 5 stars | 106 |
| 8 | LECOM at Village Square, LLC | Overall: 4 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 4 of 5 stars | Staffing: 3 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 4 of 5 stars | 110 |
| 9 | Nightingale Nursing and Rehab Center | Overall: 4 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 3 of 5 stars | Staffing: 2 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 5 of 5 stars | 139 |
| 10 | Millcreek Manor | Overall: 3 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 3 of 5 stars | Staffing: 4 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 3 of 5 stars | 144 |
| 11 | Lecom at Presque Isle, Inc | Overall: 3 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 3 of 5 stars | Staffing: 2 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 2 of 5 stars | 135 |
| 12 | Walnut Creek Nursing and RehabAbuse citation | Overall: 2 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 2 of 5 stars | Staffing: 3 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 3 of 5 stars | 115 |
| 13 | Twinbrook Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center | Overall: 2 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 2 of 5 stars | Staffing: 3 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 2 of 5 stars | 118 |
| 14 | Greenfield Healthcare and Rehabilitation CenterAbuse citation | Overall: 1 of 5 stars | Health inspections: 1 of 5 stars | Staffing: 2 of 5 stars | Quality measures: 2 of 5 stars | 133 |
Flags are Medicare’s: “Abuse citation” is its abuse icon (cited for abuse, neglect or exploitation); a Special Focus Facility has a history of serious quality problems and is inspected more often. Read the inspection reports on the home’s page.
How this list is ranked
- The Medicare overall rating (1 to 5)
- The health inspection rating
- The staffing rating
- The quality measures rating
- Still tied: the same rank, listed alphabetically.
Each step only breaks ties of the step before. Every value is published by Medicare (CMS); a missing value counts after any value. Providers without a Medicare star rating are not ranked. A city gets a list when at least 3 nursing homes there are rated.
Common questions
What are the best nursing homes in Erie according to Medicare?
Ranked by the Medicare overall star rating, Lecom at Elmwood Gardens, LLC is first place with 5 of 5 stars. The full ranking and the tie-breaks are on this page. Ratings are one piece of information: call and visit before you decide.
How is this list ranked?
By the Medicare overall rating (1 to 5), the health inspection rating, the staffing rating and the quality measures rating, in that order, all as published by Medicare (CMS). Providers equal on all of these share a rank and are listed alphabetically. Providers without a Medicare star rating are not ranked. We do not add our own scores.
Is this our recommendation?
No. The order comes only from Medicare’s star ratings, which summarize inspections, staffing, patient surveys and other measures for past patients. They do not say which provider is right for one person. Ask your doctor, call, and visit.
Sources and dates
- Provider Information — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), data updated October 1, 2026, retrieved November 14, 2026.
Lists are rebuilt from these files at every data refresh. Wording last revised November 11, 2026. Not medical advice.